Speak With Us

833-714-1330

TTY: 711

Monday - Friday: 7am - 9pm CST

Informational · No rankings

Six promises, one bill

A car insurance policy is six or seven separate promises sold as one bill. This guide explains what each promise actually pays for, why the “average premium” you read about swings by hundreds of dollars depending on who published it, and how to line up two quotes so you are comparing the same thing.

The decoder

What each coverage actually pays for

Every card below says the plain version first. Open the fine print to see the industry term, who gets paid, and the catch that surprises people at claim time.

Damage you do to other people

If you cause a crash, this pays their medical bills and repairs. It pays them, never you. This is the part your state requires.

Called
Bodily injury liability and property damage liability.
Written as
Three numbers, like 25/50/25 — $25,000 per injured person, $50,000 per crash, $25,000 for property.
The catch
State minimums were set decades ago and have not tracked medical or repair costs. If the bill runs past your limit, the balance is yours, and a plaintiff can pursue your assets and wages for it.

Damage to your car in a crash

Repairs or replaces your car after a collision, even when the crash was your fault. You pay your deductible first.

Called
Collision coverage.
Who requires it
No state does. Your lender or leasing company almost certainly does, until the car is paid off.
The catch
It pays what the car was worth the moment before the crash, not what you owe on it and not what a replacement costs today. If the payout is less than your loan balance, you still owe the difference unless you carry gap coverage.

Everything else that happens to your car

Theft, hail, flood, fire, vandalism, a deer, a cracked windshield. Anything that damages the car without a collision.

Called
Comprehensive, or "other than collision."
Usually paired
Sold alongside collision. Together the two are what people mean by "full coverage" — a marketing phrase, not a policy type.
The catch
Mechanical breakdown and normal wear are never covered. Some states allow a separate, higher deductible for glass or for wind and hail.

When the other driver has nothing

Someone hits you, it is their fault, and they have no insurance or not enough. This steps in where their policy stops.

Called
Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage (UM / UIM).
Why it matters
The Insurance Research Council estimates roughly one in seven U.S. drivers is uninsured, and the share is far higher in some states.
The catch
Required in some states, optional in others, and easy to decline without noticing. It is usually one of the cheaper lines on the bill relative to what it covers.

Your own medical bills

Pays for injuries to you and your passengers regardless of who caused the crash. What it is called depends on your state.

Called
Medical payments (MedPay) in most states; personal injury protection (PIP) in no-fault states, where it is mandatory.
Difference
PIP is broader — it can cover lost wages and household help. MedPay covers medical bills only.
The catch
In no-fault states, PIP rules also limit when you are allowed to sue the other driver. That trade-off is set by state law, not by your insurer.

The gap on a financed car

If your car is totaled while you owe more than it is worth, this covers the difference between the payout and the loan balance.

Called
Guaranteed asset protection, or gap coverage.
Sold by
Insurers as a policy add-on, and separately by dealers at financing. The dealer version is often the more expensive of the two.
The catch
Only relevant while you are underwater on the loan. Once the car is worth more than the balance, the coverage has nothing left to do and can be dropped.

By the numbers

Five sources, five different "national averages"

Every one of these figures is the published 2026 national average for full-coverage auto insurance. They disagree by more than $750 a year because each uses a different driver profile, vehicle, and state mix. Treat any single average as one opinion about a typical driver, not a price.

Full-coverage annual national average, as published in 2026
SourceAnnual averagePer monthRelative scale
Insurify2026 projection $2,158$180
Forbes AdvisorQuadrant data $2,459$205
ValuePenguinState of Auto Insurance 2026 $2,496$208
U.S. NewsJuly 2026 analysis $2,554$213
ExperianJune 2026 marketplace data $2,924$244
Spread between the lowest and highest published figure: $766 a year. Minimum-coverage averages disagree even more sharply — Forbes Advisor reports $788 a year while Experian reports $1,572 — because "minimum" means a different amount of insurance in every state.

What this means for you

If a page tells you that you are "overpaying" because your premium is above a national average, that claim is doing no work. The average includes drivers in states where coverage costs less than half what it costs in yours. The only comparison that tells you anything is the same coverage, same car, same driver, priced by different companies.

Who writes the policies

The market is unusually concentrated

Four companies collect close to sixty cents of every private auto insurance dollar in the United States. Listed by size, largest first. This is a description of market share, not a ranking, a rating, or a recommendation.

U.S. private passenger auto market share, year-end 2025 (NAIC, released March 2026)
GroupMarket shareDirect premiums earnedShare of market
State FarmMutual · exclusive agents 18.64%$69.3B
ProgressivePublic · direct and independent agents 18.60%$67.2B
Berkshire Hathaway (GEICO)Public · mostly direct 11.56%$42.7B
AllstatePublic · agents and direct 10.15%—
Top four combined
58.95%Of the entire U.S. private auto market, year-end 2025.
Top ten combined
~76%The next six groups add roughly seventeen points.
Top twenty combined
~88%Leaving about an eighth of the market to everyone else, much of it regional.

Market share measures premium volume, not service, price, or claims handling. Regional and member-owned carriers that barely register nationally are often among the largest writers in a single state — which is why the state pages below are worth checking. Source: NAIC market share reports; group totals via ValuePenguin and MoneyGeek summaries.

Work it out

Is the higher deductible worth it?

Raising your deductible lowers your premium every year and raises your bill the year you crash. The question is how long the savings take to cover the extra risk. Put your own numbers in — nothing is sent anywhere, this runs entirely in your browser.

Deductible break-even

Both figures are on your declarations page, under collision and comprehensive.

Ask your insurer to quote both deductibles and subtract. Do not estimate this — the saving varies enormously by state and vehicle.

Extra out of pocket if you claim
$500The difference between the two deductibles, owed once per claim.
Break-even
2.8 yearsGo this long without a claim and the switch has paid for itself.
Affordability check
—

This arithmetic assumes the premium saving stays flat and ignores the chance of more than one claim in the period. It is a starting point for a conversation, not a recommendation about your policy.

Method

How to compare two quotes fairly

Most quote comparisons fall apart because the two policies are not the same policy. Five checks close that gap.

  1. Match the liability limits first

    A quote at 25/50/25 will always beat a quote at 100/300/100. If the limits differ, you are not looking at a price difference, you are looking at a coverage difference.

  2. Match both deductibles

    Collision and comprehensive can carry different deductibles. Some states also allow separate glass or wind-and-hail deductibles that do not appear in the headline number.

  3. Check what got quietly dropped

    Uninsured motorist, rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, and gap coverage are common places for a cheaper quote to be cheaper. Line them up item by item.

  4. Compare the same payment schedule

    Six-month premiums and twelve-month premiums are not comparable, and paying monthly usually costs more than paying in full. Convert everything to an annual figure.

  5. Look up complaint records, not just price

    The NAIC publishes a free complaint index for every licensed insurer at naic.org, and your state insurance department publishes its own. Both are public and neither is trying to sell you anything.

Go deeper

Look up your state

Auto insurance is regulated state by state. Required liability limits, whether your state is no-fault, whether insurers may use credit history or age in pricing, and which companies write the most policies all change at the state line. Pick yours for the rules and figures that actually apply to you.

51 states

Common questions

Questions people actually ask

Does "full coverage" mean everything is covered?

No. It is a sales phrase, not a policy type. It normally means liability plus collision plus comprehensive. It does not mean unlimited limits, and it does not include gap coverage, rental reimbursement, or roadside assistance unless you added them.

Will shopping around hurt my credit score?

Insurers in most states use a credit-based insurance score, which is pulled as a soft inquiry and does not affect your credit score. A few states, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan, restrict or ban the use of credit in auto insurance pricing.

Why did my premium go up when I did nothing wrong?

Rate changes are filed with your state insurance department and apply to a whole class of drivers, not just you. Repair costs, vehicle technology, medical costs, litigation, and weather losses in your area all feed into approved rate filings. Your own record is only one input.

Is it worth keeping collision on an old car?

That is an arithmetic question. Collision pays no more than the car's actual cash value minus your deductible, so once the annual premium for collision and comprehensive approaches a meaningful share of what the car is worth, the coverage has little room to pay out. Get the specific premium for those two lines from your insurer before deciding.

Do I have to buy through a comparison site?

No. Some insurers do not appear on any comparison platform, so going direct is worth doing alongside. You can also use an independent agent, who quotes several carriers at once, or contact your state insurance department, which publishes free rate comparison guides for typical driver profiles.

Where these numbers come from

Sources

  • Market shareNational Association of Insurance Commissioners, private passenger auto market share report for year-end 2025, released March 2026. Top-ten and top-twenty totals from published summaries of the same NAIC data.
  • Premium averagesInsurify 2026 auto insurance report; Forbes Advisor car insurance rates by state (2026); ValuePenguin State of Auto Insurance 2026; U.S. News July 2026 analysis; Experian average cost of car insurance, June 2026.
  • Uninsured driversInsurance Research Council uninsured motorist estimates.
  • Complaint dataNAIC consumer complaint index and state insurance department filings.